There are still several other stories from Carl Barks that were completely "redrawn" by two other authors when he was still active and working on his beautiful stories.
Can you guess?
Pages:
1
Author
Topic: Quiz: Other Carl Bark but NOT Carl Barks
(6 messages)
Andrea
Quiz: Other Carl Bark but NOT Carl Barks
Message 1 -
2014-05-17 at 12:13:00
Andrea
Quiz: Other Carl Bark but NOT Carl Barks
Message 2 -
2014-05-17 at 12:17:05
I forgot an "s" in the topic. This is not a Quiz. It is too easy...
Runner
Quiz: Other Carl Bark but NOT Carl Barks
Message 3 -
2014-05-18 at 15:23:32
In the Scandinavian edition there were a lot of reprints which in Sweden began in 1967-1968 and the Barks stories were horribly redrawn with the beaks obviously deliberately and shortened and in general very ugly drawings of the ducks.
They were drawn as badly as the Carl Barks Library in Color editions of Donald Duck in Darkest Africa which also is a disaster. Donald Duck in To Many Pets and the horse race story (also from DD 29 in original version.) The Carl Barks Library in Color version of Donald Duck in Race to the South Seas was a little better, redrawn by Daan Jippes but even there some big changes in the savages' appearance.
Even one DD 10-pager from around 1951 (origin Junior Woodchucks) was obviously redrawn in Carl Barks Library in Color.
I assume these were redrawn in the black and white edition of Barks Library as well.
They were drawn as badly as the Carl Barks Library in Color editions of Donald Duck in Darkest Africa which also is a disaster. Donald Duck in To Many Pets and the horse race story (also from DD 29 in original version.) The Carl Barks Library in Color version of Donald Duck in Race to the South Seas was a little better, redrawn by Daan Jippes but even there some big changes in the savages' appearance.
Even one DD 10-pager from around 1951 (origin Junior Woodchucks) was obviously redrawn in Carl Barks Library in Color.
I assume these were redrawn in the black and white edition of Barks Library as well.
Andrea
Quiz: Other Carl Bark but NOT Carl Barks
Message 4 -
2014-05-18 at 16:17:30
True.
Nevertheless, I was referring to the so called "Brazilian remakes".
A joke, clearly.
Nevertheless, I was referring to the so called "Brazilian remakes".
A joke, clearly.
Germund
Quiz: Other Carl Bark but NOT Carl Barks
Message 5 -
2014-05-18 at 17:30:34
I thought of the Mickey Mouse versions Murry did of some Barks stories, such as the two shorter stories based on The Gilded Man (OS 422) and the one in Mickey Mouse #87 based on WDC 204.
Roger North
Quiz: Other Carl Bark but NOT Carl Barks
Message 6 -
2014-05-18 at 17:53:14
Quote from user: germundI thought of the Mickey Mouse versions Murry did of some Barks stories, such as the two shorter stories based on The Gilded Man (OS 422) and the one in Mickey Mouse #87 based on WDC 204.
Maybe He did germund.
Maybe He did germund.
Pages:
1