Keskustelujen arkisto

Pages: 1
Author

Topic: What do you think of my dark Scrooge story?

(6 messages)
ChriSSP
Okay, so I recently came up with what seems to me a pretty interesting story focused mainly around Scrooge. It is, however, a quite dark story considering it is supposed to be a Disney comic and I don't know if I should proceed with it, since I'm not sure if a plot like that would work.
Here's the general outline of the story: Scrooge is faced with a series of terrorizing attacks against him, in the form of shop thefts mainly, yet surpisingly none of them are focused on the Money Bin. Scrooge and his nephews immediately suspect the Beagle Boys as the culprits. Although what catches their attention is the way the thefts are carried out: everything seems very thoroughly planned, yet the culprit intentionally lets himself be find out, short after the robbery is carried out, yet always escapes. Eventually, the culprits warn Scrooge that they will go after the Money Bin for their final plan. Scrooge and his nephews, however, are prepared to fight back, and so they do. The culprits, who are indeed the Beagle Boys, are easily repeled and captured, to everyone's surpise, judging by how they were never even close to being caught during the previous crimes. It is then revealed by one of the Beagle Boys that they weren't the ones planning all the crimes, and that the mastermind let them get caught. The mastermind, however, is already in the Money Bin, most probably already where all the money is being held. Scrooge rushes to the money, in fear of the criminal getting away with it. There, he encounters the mysterious figure, who turns out to be a teen-aged boy, leaving Scrooge in awe. Shortly, the boy makes his hatred towards Scrooge obvious, and through a short flashback we learn about how he and his people were driven away from their village by Scrooge's building company (or sth like that) when he was just a kid. What he's after though, surprisingly isn't to steal Scrooge's money to restore his village, but to destroy every bit of it, to show him "how it feels like to lose everything you love".
I haven't figured out the ending yet, but it's going to include an attempt from Scrooge to redeem himself, or something along those lines. I might try to make it less dark though, since it doesn't seem much Disney-ish. However, I want all the intensity and the emotions to stay there. Let me know what you think about it and feel free to leave suggestions. This is my first story and I've put a lot of thought into it, so don't be too harsh on me.
Deyanmegara
Well, there are darker plots than yours (also more violent) already published.
It has a twist, it tries to keep the reader in tension until it comes. The culprit's story has to be intesting, so the reader won't be disappointed after the long wait, therefore, you could think a bit more on his motivation for his plan. Otherwise, it's not bad, it reminds me a bit of Barks' "Voodoo Hoodoo", because it's about revenge as well.
Mr. M
I think it's actually a very interesting idea with something wicked Scrooge did in the past coming back to hount him... however unlike "Voodoo Hoodoo" it's much more personal here which ads a lot more emotional impact.
It all depends on execution but the idea sound great here :)

If You want to see a trully dark and twisted Scrooge story check out my fan fic :)

http://panmilus.blogspot.com/2012/08/niesamowite-przygdy-wujka-sknerusa-in.html
Dutch Duckfan Down Under
I like your story. :) Some thoughts: I don't think it's too dark. You make very clever use of the Beagle Boys. Your 'villain' has a good backstory, although I think I might've heard it somewhere before.
I wouldn't want him to plan to destroy the money, though. It seems just a bit too harsh. I'd personally give the impression that all his money would be stolen, maybe by having the stores robbed completely empty. This, to give Scrooge the feeling that he will lose everything.
Having a teenager be a criminal mastermind is a bit different from the average Disney story, where they seem to be spectecularly underdeveloped, overweight, unshaven men with masks.

As for the ending, it's difficult. You can't have the kid be right, because he has done criminal things. Scrooge can't be the winner either, obviously. He'd probably have some sort of change of heart, but it's hard to say what he'd do. Maybe you should look at those Junior Woodchucks stories that Barks wrote in the 1970s.
ChriSSP
Wow, I really didn't expect people to like my story, especially as I hadn't given it much thought when I made the post! It's the first time after years of reading Disney stories that I attempt to create my very own one, including my favourite character. The positive feedback gives me motivation to work harder on it!

The reason I thought it would come off as a dark story is because of all the tension, emotions and twists it involves, something that is not all that common in Disney comics. I want it to be something that all readers would enjoy, especially those who appreciate mystery, well thought-out villains and suspense in a story.

As for the ending, I think I've figured out something (many thanks to Dutch Duckfan Down Under for giving me the general idea), which adds even more to the emotional impact of the story.

Again, all feedback is much appreciated, it really, really is a big boost to beginner like me. Thanks a lot!!
(Oh, and Mr. M, I'll make sure to give your fanfic a read later, thanks for posting it)
Dutch Duckfan Down Under
Quote from user: ChriSSPThe reason I thought it would come off as a dark story is because of all the tension, emotions and twists it involves, something that is not all that common in Disney comics. I want it to be something that all readers would enjoy, especially those who appreciate mystery, well thought-out villains and suspense in a story.
But it's good. A story without tension, emotions and twists (e.g. the average Disney comic) only has humor, or it's just bland. Mystery, well thought-out villains and suspense are all qualities. Also, I love raw emotion.
A dark story all depends on how you work it out further. And if you're writing in Disney comic style, you can't go very dark. It's sort of impossible. (Exceptions: Rosa's "The Universal Solvent" and "The Incredible Shrinking Tightwad", which are horror stories.)

Quote from user: ChriSSPAgain, all feedback is much appreciated, it really, really is a big boost to beginner like me. Thanks a lot!!
Just a bit of advice from a fellow amateur: don't think you're there yet. I have wonderful story ideas (even if I say so myself), but I usually ruin them in the excecution. By filling it up with bad and useless jokes, for example. Or by focusing on the wrong aspects of the story. Watch out for that. Remember, here's where you decide how dark it's going to be. Success!
Pages: 1