Keskustelujen arkisto

Pages: 1
Author

Topic: Magica vs. Scrooge stories without the dime...

(8 messages)
Mr. M
Do you recall any stories where Magica was the villian however number one dime wasn't her goal or mentioned at all?

We all know Barks :
- "Isle of Golden Geese"
- "Rug Riders in the Sky"

And Rosa's :
- "The Quest for Kalevala" (where she was after Sampo)

But other then Ducktales episode "Rider of the lost harp" were she was after the magical harp of Hellen of Troy that Scrooge found... are there any other examples?
Gyro Gearloose
There's also a story by Marco Rota published during Gemstone's run (I think it was "The Golden Throne" or something like that). Mostly set in Australia, it has Magica trying to beat Scrooge to a golden throne fused out of a meteor that she knows to have alchemical powers. That particular story was beautifully drawn, but rather disappointing plot-wise (Scrooge and Magica never even meet, let alone confront each other, in the whole story). However, I do like the idea of Magica frequently vying with Scrooge for occult/mythological treasures; it gives creators the opportunity to use her in more than one type of story. There are only so many wrinkles writers can put on the "Theft of Old Number One" plot
Sirredknee
This one, too, if I remember correctly:
http://coa.inducks.org/s.php?c=W+DD++101-02
Artemi
Quote from user: Gyro GearlooseThere's also a story by Marco Rota published during Gemstone's run (I think it was "The Golden Throne" or something like that). Mostly set in Australia, it has Magica trying to beat Scrooge to a golden throne fused out of a meteor that she knows to have alchemical powers. That particular story was beautifully drawn, but rather disappointing plot-wise (Scrooge and Magica never even meet, let alone confront each other, in the whole story). However, I do like the idea of Magica frequently vying with Scrooge for occult/mythological treasures; it gives creators the opportunity to use her in more than one type of story. There are only so many wrinkles writers can put on the "Theft of Old Number One" plot
I agree. We need more stories of this kind.
Ramapith
Quote from user: Gyro GearlooseThere's also a story by Marco Rota published during Gemstone's run (I think it was "The Golden Throne" or something like that). Mostly set in Australia, it has Magica trying to beat Scrooge to a golden throne fused out of a meteor that she knows to have alchemical powers. [...] I do like the idea of Magica frequently vying with Scrooge for occult/mythological treasures
I was an Egmont editor at the time Marco submitted this story, and I was at some weekly editorial meetings where its development was discussed. The story in part grew out of Marco's editor (at that time, my then-colleague Lars Bergström) actively encouraging him to use Magica in this fashion. The rest of us were all for it; it comes so naturally that I can't believe it's not done more often.
Coolwater
Quote from user: sirredkneeThis one, too, if I remember correctly:

http://coa.inducks.org/s.php?c=W+DD++101-02

One of my favourite ones of Strobl. Very remarkable in this story is that Scrooge agrees with handing his number one dime over to Magica in exchange for the supposed giant golden nugget, explaining that the nugget was "much more worth" than the dime. I cannot recall any other story where he would do such. I can only think of some stories where he would give his dime away if his or his nephews lives are seriously at risk (e.g. in "Oddball Odyssey", US 40, where the sorceress turned the nephews into pigs).
GeoX
I remember reading that story and thinking it was okay; you have to admit, though, that having Scrooge agree to a trade like that isn't evidence of dynamism; it's just a writer just screwing up and having him act wildly out-of-character.
Mr. M
This one have an interesting concept :
http://coa.inducks.org/story.php?c=D+2000-043

In the story Huey, Duey and Luey find out that they had a pirate ancestor whos fortune was larger then Scooges (yep..) and - just like Scrooge he had a lucky first dime which got sunk with his ship. The story about the pirate end-up on tv and Scrooge freaks out since now Magica will learn about it and try to get the coin from the sunken ship it will give her the Midas Touch and she will become richer then Scrooge (plus by creating gold by will she will make the pirce of gold hit rock bottom) So Scrooge, Donald and the boys race agianst Magica to find the lost ship and get the coin... well you know how those things go ;)

Still an interesting concetp since they where trying stop Magica from getting something else that would give her the Midas powers, which is pretty bad on it's own...
Pages: 1