Keskustelujen arkisto

Pages: 1
Author

Topic: Pixelated artwork

(13 messages)
Arthur
Has any else noticed that some of Boom's comics look very pixelated? It looks like they received low-resolution artwork from Italy.
See the example below. You can see that the text that Boom puts in is much smoother than the rest. I think it looks very bad.
http://www.wolfstad.com/dcw/temp/boom_pixels.jpg
Indiana Goof
I have noticed that, I personally don't care for that sort of thing as I prefer the human touch to computers. ;)
Gerd Syllwasschy
Goof, this is the result of using computers. You didn't have those jaggies back in the analog days.
Indiana Goof
That's what I said. I'm afraid you misunderstood my post.
I was stating that I didn't care for that sort of thing (pixel problems and using computers). That's the reason why I never like to use computers when creating or sharing my own material unless absolutely necessary.
Kneon
Gemstone used to send me 600 dpi pages, which was actually twice the standard resolution for most American comics (which are usually 300 to 400 dpi, depending on the publisher.) You wouldn't see any "jaggies" on those pages unless you zoomed in pretty close with Photoshop. Could just be a low-res source file, yeah. Maybe they're printing from compressed PDFs?
Indiana Goof
Quote from user: KneonGemstone used to send me 600 dpi pages, which was actually twice the standard resolution for most American comics (which are usually 300 to 400 dpi, depending on the publisher.) You wouldn't see any "jaggies" on those pages unless you zoomed in pretty close with Photoshop. Could just be a low-res source file, yeah. Maybe they're printing from compressed PDFs?
That would be my guess, as that explanation seems to make the most sense. Going by what you said, Gemstone has the right idea. I've used Photoshop in the past for scanning inked pages and around 600 was usually what I preferred just to be safe.

So yeah, maybe the above is using compressed PDFs, but I honestly can't figure out why? I mean, wouldn't one think that they would want the best resolution possible?
Timoro
Text is always smoother, because they are vector graphics fonts instead of pixel raster image graphics. Artwork is always pixel raster image 300 - 600 dpi.
There is always possibility to make bad PDF:s out of good quality tiff's and so.

Timo
Charlie Brown
Oh. The same in the "The Life and Times of Scrooge McDuck" Vol 1: you can see pixels in the fullpage artworks inside the front- and back cover. Luckily not in the stories.

Quote from user: KneonGemstone used to send me 600 dpi pages, which was actually twice the standard resolution ..
That's the way to do it. I do the same with scanned graphics for books.
Quackpack
Well, since the comics themselves are kinda cheap, this doesn't surpise me at all...
Arthur
Quote from user: quackpackWell, since the comics themselves are kinda cheap, this doesn't surpise me at all...
At $2.99 per comic I expect better quality stories. I have Disney comics from dozens of countries in my collection and I have never seen such badly pixelated artwork before.

Comics like the Incredibles and Cars with new stories look nice and sharp, but the pixels show up in a lot of the Italian stories.

I just checked the D-coded "Gold Hunt" art in Uncle Scrooge 387 and that looks pretty bad too. Are both Italy and Denmark providing BOOM! with low-res stories? Or did BOOM! get the Gold Hunt story from Italy because it had already been changed to a 3-tier format?

Either BOOM! is doing something wrong or they need to demand 300-600 DPI artwork from Italy. Otherwise they should start using stories from another source, like directly from Egmont.
Charlie Brown
I just got the Donald Duck Classics hardcover. The same here: you can see every pixel in the blown up pictures on the first and last pages. That shouldn't happen! There must be high resolution scans out there. BOOM should work together with Egmont. I have never seen pixels in one of their books, even in the cheap ones.
Scarpomaniak
Pixels were visible again in the comic book published by Gemstone, the Walt Disney Treasures - 80 yeas of Innowations, but there were only one, Brazilian comics.
Quackpack
Reducing the image size might help.
Pages: 1