Stefan,
Thanks for the info. I figured that the ratings must be weighted somehow....
I'm confused by "votes averaged over story S or over all stories"--what does "over all stories" mean, and when does that apply? When there's only one vote for a particular story, as in the examples I cited?
Could you possibly show me (with numbers) how the formula actually leads to the result in the cases I cited? That might help make things clear.
Elaine
-----Original Message-----
From: Stefan Persson [mailto:spe at inducks.org]
Sent: Friday, July 31, 2009 4:05 AM
To: Elaine Ramshaw
Cc: dcml at nafsk.se
Subject: Re: INDUCKS ratings
On 2009-07-31 04:54, Elaine Ramshaw wrote:
> Can anyone explain to me the way the ratings of stories on INDUCKS are
> calculated? I was looking at Carl Fallberg stories, for instance; S63053
> is rated 8.1/10 with one vote, and the one vote is 7. Likewise, S64054
> is rated 8.2/10 with one vote, and the one vote is 10. What am I
> missing, here?
See the bottom of http://coa.inducks.org/recommend.php?top100=1 :
<<<
http://coa.inducks.org/img/formulaTop100.png
Ratings are computed using the formula shown left with r the weighed rating, v
are votes averaged over story s or over all stories, n is the number of votes of
each story and m the minimum number of votes required to be listed in the top
100. Some additional formula, not displayed here, is used in the rating.
>>>
Stefan
Pages:
1
Author
Topic: 200908
(4 messages)
Elaine Ramshaw
INDUCKS ratings
Message 1 -
2009-08-01 at 04:22:36
Santiago García
Gottfredson?
Message 2 -
2009-08-10 at 11:20:39
Joakim Gunnarsson:
>>I just posted some photos of a few MM dailies (labeled as Gottfredson artwork) on my blog. I doubt Gottfredson drew them and have my own theory about who it was...
Go check it out at http://sekvenskonst.blogspot.com/
and let me know what you think.
Hum... Seems Manuel Gonzales' artwork to me.
Nice blog!
Santiago.
>>I just posted some photos of a few MM dailies (labeled as Gottfredson artwork) on my blog. I doubt Gottfredson drew them and have my own theory about who it was...
Go check it out at http://sekvenskonst.blogspot.com/
and let me know what you think.
Hum... Seems Manuel Gonzales' artwork to me.
Nice blog!
Santiago.
John Chadwick
The Toon Treasury of Classic Children's Comics
Message 3 -
2009-08-22 at 01:47:30
The new book The Toon Treasury of Classic Children's Comics was
released earlier this week. My copy arrived today. It contains
reprints of Carl Barks' "Hypno-Gun", "Bee Bumbler" and "Tralla La", a
reprint of Barks' cover from WDC&S #94 and several non-Disney stories
by Walt Kelly.
released earlier this week. My copy arrived today. It contains
reprints of Carl Barks' "Hypno-Gun", "Bee Bumbler" and "Tralla La", a
reprint of Barks' cover from WDC&S #94 and several non-Disney stories
by Walt Kelly.
Marc Newman
Toon Treasury
Message 4 -
2009-08-24 at 10:12:16
I got my copy on Saturday as well. I was able to help them source a
bunch of the final comics they needed (mostly DCs but the copy of Gerald
McBoing Boing they used was ours as well). Spiegelman told me that he
considered the four American masters of the children's comic book to be
Barks, Kelly, Mayer, and Stanley. I couldn't agree more. Glad to see a
lot of Barks and Kelly in there and this thing should be a great
Christmas present option for years to come.
Marc Newman
HouseofComics.com
>
> The new book The Toon Treasury of Classic Children's Comics was
> released earlier this week. My copy arrived today. It contains
> reprints of Carl Barks' "Hypno-Gun", "Bee Bumbler" and "Tralla La", a
> reprint of Barks' cover from WDC&S #94 and several non-Disney stories
> by Walt Kelly.
>
>------------------------------------------------------------------------
>
bunch of the final comics they needed (mostly DCs but the copy of Gerald
McBoing Boing they used was ours as well). Spiegelman told me that he
considered the four American masters of the children's comic book to be
Barks, Kelly, Mayer, and Stanley. I couldn't agree more. Glad to see a
lot of Barks and Kelly in there and this thing should be a great
Christmas present option for years to come.
Marc Newman
HouseofComics.com
>
> The new book The Toon Treasury of Classic Children's Comics was
> released earlier this week. My copy arrived today. It contains
> reprints of Carl Barks' "Hypno-Gun", "Bee Bumbler" and "Tralla La", a
> reprint of Barks' cover from WDC&S #94 and several non-Disney stories
> by Walt Kelly.
>
>------------------------------------------------------------------------
>
Pages:
1