Keskustelujen arkisto

Pages: 1 2
Author

Topic: Manga versions of Barks stories

(28 messages)
Baar Baar Jinx
Manga versions of Barks stories Message 16 - 2013-07-19 at 15:37:29
Quote from user: BenadiktBecause of my curiosity I bought the 4 German issues two years ago. They look terrible compared to Barks art. There is absolutely NO REASON to buy these, except If you are collecting every single issue where Barks has been involved just a little bit.
I am also curious as to how the seeds for this project were sown. Was it thought that Japanese audiences would not like Barks' art for some reason?
Charlie Brown
Manga versions of Barks stories Message 17 - 2013-07-20 at 05:20:54
Quote from user: BenadiktBecause of my curiosity I bought the 4 German issues two years ago. They look terrible compared to Barks art. There is absolutely NO REASON to buy these, except If you are collecting every single issue where Barks has been involved just a little bit.
Are you able to scan a page? I would like to see the art.
Cacou
Manga versions of Barks stories Message 18 - 2013-07-20 at 23:57:55
Robb_K
Manga versions of Barks stories Message 19 - 2013-07-21 at 06:43:31
Quote from user: cacou

Which Barks story is THAT?
Dutch Duckfan Down Under
Manga versions of Barks stories Message 20 - 2013-07-21 at 11:56:49
It's Super Snooper.
Robb_K
Manga versions of Barks stories Message 21 - 2013-07-21 at 15:16:38
Quote from user: Dutch Duckfan Down UnderIt's Super Snooper.
Fooiee! I think they'd have been better off getting Barks' drawings in Japan.
Benadikt
Manga versions of Barks stories Message 22 - 2013-07-22 at 02:08:06
Quote from user: Charlie BrownAre you able to scan a page? I would like to see the art.
cacou has already shown one page; I can show some more examples when I have found the books from the boxes where they are stored.
Robb_K
Manga versions of Barks stories Message 23 - 2013-07-24 at 05:42:46
Quote from user: BenadiktQuote from user: Charlie BrownAre you able to scan a page? I would like to see the art.
cacou has already shown one page; I can show some more examples when I have found the books from the boxes where they are stored.
I can't wait to see them.
Charlie Brown
Manga versions of Barks stories Message 24 - 2013-07-26 at 16:17:18
Cacou, thanks for posting a page.
The isn't even close to Barks design and script. And not close to any manga I know. No wonder the stories got not printed often.
Robb_K
Manga versions of Barks stories Message 25 - 2013-07-31 at 13:55:25
Quote from user: Charlie BrownCacou, thanks for posting a page.

The isn't even close to Barks design and script. And not close to any manga I know. No wonder the stories got not printed often.
Nevertheless, I'd like to see them all. I am curious about the different artists they used.
FAa
Manga versions of Barks stories Message 26 - 2013-08-06 at 05:48:35
(click the images for larger version)
The start of The Mad Chemist


Page 3 and 4 of Something Fishy

And two pages of really weird art from The Mighty Duck
Charlie Brown
Manga versions of Barks stories Message 27 - 2013-08-06 at 07:30:20
Thanks for making the photos. The first pages are not very special - just a little bit irregular panel design. The last one is really weird. But non of the pages remind me of manga art. For me manga is special in panel layout and style of drawing. And the second did not change here.
Roger North
Manga versions of Barks stories Message 28 - 2013-08-06 at 11:38:22
I have a reprint of the Original Version of The Mad Chemist in Donald Duck Adventures (Gladstone Series) #15 and the original version of Mighty Duck in Walt Disney Giant #3 although technically it wasn't Carl Barks who wrote that story it was Tony Strobl and Huey Dewey and Louie weren't in that version.
Pages: 1 2