Keskustelujen arkisto

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23
Author

Topic: 199611

(342 messages)
James E. Smith III
Dear Don:

I'm sorry, I didn't mean to sound as critical as I did. Believe me, if
I were in your presence, I would be on the ground groveling before you
and your genius. What made me say that, was I was just listening the new
Menken (he did the music for the Little Mermaid, Beauty and the Beast,
Aladdin, etc,) and I was really moved the the tune (whose name escapes
me) that was played when Scrooge recounciles with his nephew and niece.
You know, when he comes in and asks if they will allow him to enter their
home. .
And they say, "welcome home, Uncle Scrooge, wecome home to family."

It was a nice touch. Very emotional. I guess that's what I was thinking
on. It probably wouldn't have worked anyway.

James Smith III

--------------------------------
End of Disney comics Digest V96 Issue #243
******************************************
Dave Rawson
(Email removed) (Ole R. Nielsen):
ORN> I would love to see Cavazzano's "Casablanca" and "La Strada" [...]
ORN> Maybe Gladstone would give it a shot?

Boy! I would LOVE to see someone get this into the hands of
English-language readers. What a delight that would be. Bob Foster
showed me some of the "Casablanca" story when we were teaching with Will
Eisner in Dublin.

I think it could be a wonderful introduction to the global scope of
first-class comic creators employed world-wide by the vast Disney
affiliation (not unlike the Medici patronage of Florentine renown). This
really deserves to happen and would play to the strength of the
vast, high-quality material extant, rather than performing apologia for
the current blinkered, provincial American tastes.

My direct and pragmatic experience is that if you put something before
the public which TO THEM is obviously better, they will respond.
However, the public will never ask for or choose what it doesn't know
exists.

ORN> Unfortunately they are only credited in the original Italian
ORN> editions, so even popular artists like Cavazzano, Massimo de Vita,
ORN> and Scarpa are quite anonymous and unknown outside their home
ORN> country.

May there be a lingering on the soul of those ultimately responsible for
this criminal policy of non-attribution!

(Email removed) (Don Rosa):
DonR> The point of that gag "woodchuck"... uh... poem? is not some sort
DonR> of question about "inate ability" or whatever...

Right. It's not the point of the tongue-twister, but it is the point of
the distinction between the proper uses of "would" and "could" which
was what was asked by the question I was answering, "Should would be
could?"

DonR> it's just a cute lil' children's wordplay on the various ways to
DonR> use the words "wood" and "chuck" in a short sentence.

In my experience it was a memorable, mellifluous way taught to enable
children to remember the subtle difference between "would" and "could,"
similar and superior to "You can if you will, you may if you might!"

DonR> So if you stick an errant "could" in there, you may be making a
DonR> valid comment about the abilities of a burrowing mammal, but
DonR> you've strayed from the gag.

Not at all. It heightens the charm of the tongue-twister. The use of
proper grammar creates the subtle distinction between the two words,
"would/could," adding content to the tongue-twister that wouldn't be
there otherwise, and it's this distinction that helps give lasting
meaning to the tongue-twister for me.

DonR> The only way there's a purpose behind it is with all
"wood/would"s.

In my experience, there's more than only words which pronounce the same,
but which have different meanings like "wood/would." This rich trove of
a tongue-twister also teaches common meter and emphasis, rhyme,
assonance, consonance, and irony, and does so in a delightful, painless,
non-pedantic way. As I said, it's my favorite by far.

DonR> I would never suggest that the particular ways I pick are any
DonR> better than the next.

Ah, well, I guess I'm a lout, but I like doing it different ways. It's
fun and it works quite well.

DonR> Anytime this is violated, it's simply when the hired-editors
aren't
DonR> familiar with the comics they are editting

Well, I think Byron's eminently familiar with what he's editing and
doing a damn fine job to boot. In fact, I think he's an enormous benefit
to the Disney character story-telling community and we're lucky to have
him.

Harry Fluks <(Email removed)>:
HF> Every artist has its limits to work with. For instance the size of
HF> the canvas for a painter like Rembrandt. Or the number of pages of
HF> a novel. Or the time (and budget) of a movie.

Well said! I often think that the chaffing struggle against inherent
boundaries is what gives lasting art its transcendent quality. I cannot
define what is or is not art. In fact, my stated claim is that "All art
converges at the ineffable."

Regardless, if Don's work continues to be enjoyed well into the next
millennia, I guarantee folks will call it Art!

Byron Erickson <(Email removed)>:
BE> a few greedy men got a bright idea over 30 years ago.

I didn't know that! Eerie. Uncanny. I'd like to know the names of those
folks. At least in my make-believe story, Scrooge ended up out-smarting
the smarties (though I don't see the villains wearing wooden barrels
which is how I imperfectly recall writing things almost a half-decade
ago -- and if I didn't, I should have!).

(Email removed):
DD> The target markets would be places like airport newsstands, bus
DD> stations, gas stations, souvenir shops at tourist attractions,
DD> and hospital gift shops. Basically places where parents would
DD> find themselves stuck with cranky kids in need of amusement,
DD> but Disney Stores and regular bookstores, too.

I think this is a very good approximation of exactly the proper
mass-market venue to supplement the narrow-market comic book stores.
I'd add that Disney Adventures and Archie are doing VERY well at the
grocery store checkout stands, one of the most powerful locations for
impulse buying in existence. The digest-sized material means it's more
physically stable than standard comics, too.

If one could get material into such a coveted spot, we see that one
could do quite well. I don't know what it would take to get Gladstone
digest-sized material shoe-horned into those Disney Adventures' racks,
say during the last week of the monthly cycle, but I'd guess a threshold
of 20% profit to Disney higher than what they now earn in that last
quarter-cycle. However, I doubt that they track things that closely,
unfortunately. Regardless, proven reward is always the best incentive to
cause change.

DD> capital-A Art...? The only true test of that is Time

Even that notion is dubious. Rather, it is one test (if not the most
common test), but not the only test. I make this fine distinction not to
be argumentative, but because I find that others have given this serious
thought that I find interesting.

For instance, some artists destroy their work after it is shown. Does it
mean it never was art because it didn't endure? That question
goes to the heart of their work. What of Da Vinci's Sforza monument, or
his "Battle of Anghieri," two acclaimed masterpieces which
didn't survive his lifetime? Surely they were art.

Which raises the question, "How is art valued?" Some artists have
thought about this, too, and deliberately inverted the process of
valuation; monumental artists, particularly.

Walter de Maria has created "The Lightning Field"
[http://www.diacenter.org/ltproj/lf/lf.html] in New Mexico which is
studded with an enormous grid (a rectangle one mile by one kilometer in
size) of huge, steel spikes, twenty-feet or more high, which draw
lightning from the sky and safely ground the strikes so that one may
walk among this powerful force of nature.

But because the experience of his art is removed and remote, one must
decide to value the experience BEFORE one has it, else they would not
seek it out. Traditionally, one has the experience of apprehending the
creation, and then deciding whether the experience had value.

I find all this fascinating and hope I wasn't too boring in discussing
these fundamental concerns some of us creators consider...

--
riverrun past Eve's and Adam's from swerve of shore to bend of bay
(Email removed) -=*=- http://users.aol.com/dcrawson/home.htm
Shaun M. Knowler
Didn't Donaldo El Quacko commit suicide at the end of "Dangerous
Disguise"? I dunno about you guys, but that's the impression I got from
the action of saying "Goodbye cruel world!" then throwing himself out a
window! (and speaking of deaths in Disney stories!)

-$haun
Vsaari
Christer Hanssen wrote:

> The other day I read Donald Duck in Ancient Persia (FC275) and there the
> "mad scientist" actually dies! Well, he is redused to dust. This is the
> first time I ever have seen a living person die in the Duck universe. Are
> there other stories where that happens or is this one a rare incident?

Scrooge's father dies in Rosa's Life of Scrooge part 9. The actual death is
not shown, but he is shown alive and later as a ghost and his dead body is
also shown.

--
Ville Saari EMail: (Email removed)
Tallbergin puistotie 7 B 21 Phone: +358 9 682 2226
00200 Helsinki
FINLAND /dev/null: write failed, file system is full
Daniel C. Kenny
GARY:
sorry about the mix up on the USA "library" albums. I must have missed your
message the other day. Thanks for clearing that up.
KRITON:
A Rosa library had better be produced one day (not until after Don's retirement
though, we wouldn't want to get gypped). seriously though, isn't the USA album
series doing a special Rosa miniseries this summer or next summer? Since
they've already printed his signature LO$, does anybody have any ideas what the
series will be (maybe all the Rosa sequels). In some ways, that can be
considered a library.
JAMES SMITH
i haven't seen the play "a Christmas Carol", nor have I heard that Alan Mencken
tune, but I do know what scene you're talking about. It is very touching (the
Movie version benefits from Alistair Sim's brilliant portrayal of the reformed
Scrooge)
I do think,however, that Don did do a scene similar to this in Chapter twelve.
It's after $crooge has defeated the Beagle Boys and is getting into his funk
again, when the nephews tell him that "we'll be your Family now". That sounds
just like that line in "A Christmas Carol"
I thought Don handled that scene wonderfully. In fact the only section in LO$
that I think, could have been expanded was the $crooge-Goldie relationship.
Goldie was in it for a very short itme (don says she had a larger role in his
more comical original script), and even in "Hearts of the Yukon", the two were
only together for a brief time. I think a great story could be about what
happened in that month when $crooge got Goldie to work on his claim. Since so
little has been told of that point (all we know is that Goldie stormed off
angry) any story is a possibility.
Danny Coenen
I am sorry I haven`t written lately, but I was, and i still kind of am
that two mails I sent to this list a couple or three weeks ago never
appeared on the digest, and I didn`t have copies, of course. This one
better get through, or I`ll just have to kill myself ;-). This net just
seems to be getting way too crowded!

DON:
Personally I`d be very interested in a story about HD&L`s parents, or the
return of Scrooges sisters, but it would probably cause lots of discussion
as well. I agree with you when you say that it would be very hard, if not
impossible to find a good storyline for a story like this. But, on the
other hand- didn`t people think that it was impossible to condense all
US stories by Barks into one logical biography? So, I guess if you can`t,
nobody ever will be capable of doing such a job.
As for the return of Scrooge`s sisters, did you have any particular ideas
how that could have happened? Now that you won`t write this story, maybe
you can share your ooriginal plan with us???

ALL:
I am way behind on reading my digests, so just in case somebody had a question
for me, I`d really thank you if you could ask me again. I doubt that I`ll
ever catxh up if I`ll read all of the old stuff.

Currently I am reading "Insomnia" by Stephen King, and theres a line in there
that says something about a "Beagle Boys type mask". I was really surprised
to find that in a novel of an American author, since our beloved comic
characters are everything but frequently known by especially the younger
people. Maybe Mr. King is one of the numerous popular Barks fans, too?
Danny Coenen
Kopernikusstr. 18 Tel. :
(049)2461/56129
D-52428 Juelich
Germany EU e-mail :
(Email removed)
Marco Barlotti
KRITON:

Yup, that was it! It was my beloved story written by Mazzanti and drawn by
Gatto!
Only, the Italian version had Donald go into year 2001 (40 years from
"now"), so he didn't need any long-life drug to meet himself in the future!
But every other detail is correct, including Donald trying to pay his
ice-cream with the "future-dollar" he had.
I read again the story yesterday after many years. I noticed a little
inconsistency in that it's not explained exactly HOW Donald manages to go
back to "now", but apart from that I still liked it a lot! And it was fun to
read that "since 1970 cars don't use gasoline any more, they are
atom-propelled"!
Marco
Anders Engwall
Christer Hanssen:

> The other day I read Donald Duck in Ancient Persia (FC275) and there the
> "mad scientist" actually dies! Well, he is redused to dust. This is the
> first time I ever have seen a living person die in the Duck universe. Are
> there other stories where that happens or is this one a rare incident?

There's of course "King $crooge the First" (US 71), where the villain
ends up taking an antidote to the life-prolonging substance he had
taken 4000 years earlier... I guess that counts as suicide, even.

---
Anders Engwall

"Alle man står still som en stum fisk, tills vi hittar den knyckta stångkorven!"
Markoff
I'm probably making an ass of myself by asking a question everyone else
already knows, but here it is: is Floyd Gottfredson still alive, or dead?
BBranvold
Marc Chapman wrote Re: Comic Stores returning unsold comics rather than
throwing
them away. There are 2 store types in play in the U.S.; one is the direct
sale
comic book store, and the second is the newstands/grocery store.
I own a direct sale comic book store. We order from one big distribution
company
(Diamond dist.) all of our Gladstones. What I order is what I keep (no
returns).
Therefore I need to order what I think I will sell. If I order more and do
not sell it,
that is money out of my pocket.
The other store type is the newstand/grocery store. They get comics from a
local
distibution company that deals with all magazines and comics. The local
distributor
gets all of its magazines and comics on a returnable basis. What they do
not sell
they get a full refund on and "throw away" the comic. The discount the local

company
offers is about 1/2 what Diamond offers to me. Therefore I can order comics
with a "low" discount and return what I do not sell, or order with a better
discount and order
only what I think I will sell. With comic stores ordering "so close" to what
they normally sell, there are not as many "extras" for customers later on.
So when you
say "Comic Stores" there are 2 types in the U.S. ---Barry---
Deckerd
The other day, I put out a call for some kind Dane
to supply me with a copy of Julklassikere #3, the
annual hardcover pocket-sized collection of Disney
Christmas stories Egmont publishes in Denmark, since
I wouldn't be going to Europe this year. A kind Dane
has in fact answered my call and I'm told the book
is even now on its way to my eager hands. This book
is rapidly becoming a Christmas tradition for me,
even if it does take me until March to read it all
the way through... The stories are mostly Italian,
and lately this has been my most exposure to the
Disney comics produced in that part of the world.
(That dome on the money bin takes some getting
used to...)

--Dwight Decker
Wilmer Rivers
First, some old matters unrelated to disney comics, to dispose of:

Harry writes:
>> "How much wood would a woodchuck chuck, if a woodchuck could chuck wood?"
>I know this one, but with "would" in stead of "could". Should could be would?

The "could" is important, because it makes it harder to say (at least
fast). Saying "woodchuck would chuck" is easy, because it's the same
thing twice, but saying "woodchuck could chuck" requires you to
shift gears in your tongue, sort of, so it's a "tongue twister". The
toughest one of these is "She sells sea shells by the sea shore," a
sentence which you just **can't** say fast 3 times in a row without
mixing up one or more of the "s" and "sh" sounds.

Not to be outdone, Harald offers:
> BTW: I know a _working_ possibility to utter "had" 11(!) times in a
> row in a (well two) English sentences with only some words before
> and after them. Anybody interested? ;-)

I didn't know that one. But here's something similar: by adding the
right punctuation, the string of words
that that is is that that is not is not is not that it
can be made maningful. Is it obvious how to do it? (The answer is
given further down in this post).

Harry also advises:
>"Homo sapiens non urinat in ventum"
And as the late Jim Croce reminded us, you don't tug on Superman's cape,
either. (In case you didn't know, Superman got married about 3 weeks
ago. The comics shops here in the USA were distributing printed invi-
tations to the wedding! Do you suppose they would do something like
that for the 50th anniversary of Uncle Scrooge? In your dreams!)

Don Rosa replies to Dan Kenny:
> "a pioneer like Rosa"? Puh-lease! I'm surely one of the world's most
> recent Duck writers or artists!

Well, you know the definition of a pioneer: that's a guy who's lying
face down in the field, with an arrow in his back. So are you a pioneer
or not? :)

Oh here's how to make the string of words
that that is is that that is not is not is not that it
mean something. You add punctuation as follows:
That that is, is; that that is not, is not. Is not that it?

Now on to real disney-comics discussion. Don Rosa writes of scenarios
for bringing HD&L's parents back into a story:
> A) They are found and HD&L go to live with them and leave Unca Donald
> -- sad. B) They are found and HD&L decide to disown them or something
> so they can stay with Unca Donald -- sad and weird. C) They are found
> after 60n years and then lost again -- very sad! D) They are found
> DEAD -- rilly, rilly sad! E) They aren't found at all -- so whatsa
> point?

How about a storyline more typical of family-style TV situation comedies
from the mid-1950s era in which such a story would be set? The standard
plot device would be that Della and her husband - let's call him "Daddy
Duck", for lack of something better - show up to collect the boys now
that Daddy has recuperated from the terrible accident involving the
firecracker underneath the chair. Della and Daddy take the boys home,
where everyone tries to make the best of it, but it's obvious that HD&L
are homesick for their "real" home with Unca Donald (who tries to put
on a brave little sailor's bluster, but who is clearly lonesome too).
Even Della and Daddy are sad, seeing how depressed the boys are. So one
night while the boys are in bed, there's a terrible explosion in the
living room, and we see Daddy writhing in pain amidst the wreckage of
a blown-up armchair. Daddy has to go back to the hospital, and of
course HD&L must again be shipped off to their Unca Donald's home. The
story of course ends with a scene showing that Daddy has booby-trapped
his own chair and faked aggravating his old injury, just to make things
turn out for the best all around. The 1950s-style show would end with
everyone sharing hugs with everyone else, tissues are filled with tears,
and it's time for the commercial for Ovaltine or Bosco.

And as for the death of Scrooge, I think that he should not die but
merely fade away. At age 100, he heads back to the Klondike, where he
has some "unfinished business". But he seems to have finished all his
other business back in Duckburg before he leaves, including leaving a
will. Concerned about the old duck's state of health and possibly his
state of mind, Donald and HD&L follow behind as soon as they learn of
Scrooge's departure for the Yukon. They track him far up White Agony
Creek, where they find that a terrible avalanche has blocked off the
valley. No trace is found of Scrooge. Eventually Donald and HD&L
reluctantly give up the search, and he is presumed to be buried at the
bottom of tons of ice and snow. But is he really? All we know for
certain is that sometimes, when the Aurora Borealis casts "Flying
Dutchman"-style reflections off the clouds, it seems that the images
of two ducks can be seen, one of them with golden hair. Are they in
fact images projected off the bottom of the block of ice and snow in the
avalanche? Or are they real reflections of two very-much alive ducks,
digging for gold in a hidden valley? Or is it just our imagination,
as we see in the clouds a reflection of our own memories of a duck who
will forevermore be prospecting in the sky, always searching for
Another Rainbow? We shall never know. All that is left for us to
ponder is a humble-looking tombstone which Scrooge purchased before he
left Duckburg, with the instructions that it was be to used for his
own grave - even if it was empty. The epitaph on the tombstone says
mysteriously: "Just a Poor Old Man".

Wilmer Rivers
Harald Havas
DWIGHT
Okay, dictionary time, guys!

1.
> but it just dawned on me that German
>"ziehen" and "zeichnen" are rather similar and cover both
>senses of English "draw." Way back in the grey mists of the
>dawn of time, was there a common Germanic root that brought
>forth all these words?

1.1
"ziehen" ("draw" in the sense of "pull") goes back to Indoeuropean
" *deuk- " meaning "pull", which has dozens of offspring in recent
German and other languages. In English it evolved over "teon" (Old
English) to present day "tow".
("*" means no one has seen or heard that word, It's just deducted)

1.2
"zeichnen", according to my dictionary, came to be after the word
"Zeichen" (= sign), which comes from "zeihen", a rarely used German
word meaning "accuse, point to" - both having the distant origin in
Indoeuropean " *deik- " meaning "to show". This has an Old English
offspring too in, surprise, "teon", but this time in the sense of
"accuse"

My dictionary never states any similarity between the two, but it's
clear that they both, "pull" and "show", traveled a long time side by
side...

1.3
"draw", to complete this entry, finds its root over (Old) German
"tragen", meaning "carry", back to Latin "trahere" ("pull, draw,
drag"). Webster's also has about a dozen more meanings for
"to draw" BTW...

2.
>Except that applies in English mainly to writing, not drawing
>(which is "doodling"). If I read the dictionary right, "scribble"
>comes from the Latin "scribere," to write. It would be interesting
>(to me, anyway) to trace how the Latin word became the debased
>form of the act in English, while in German it apparently displaced
>the native word for the concept entirely (Schreiben). Maybe Harald
>would know...

2.1
Sorry, what's the question again? Well, "write" seems to be the
original Germanic term for the act - meaning something like "carving,
tearing" - German "reissen" carries the last meaning. The act of
writing was mostly carving in former times: the German word
"Buchstabe", meaning (a single) "letter", still shows that: "Stab"
means stick and "Buche" is the tree called beech, were the "runes"
were carved in...
How "srcibble" becam a debased word? No idea! But it sounds like a
diminuitive (or perogative) of (the) "scribe", which is still respectable,
n'est-ce pas? "To draw" in latin, BTW, was "pingere" - which ended as
"paint" in contemporal English.
Anyway, always glad to be of help ;-)

(End of dictionary time)

STILL DWIGHT (RE: had times 11)
>Wait a minute! You made two sentences out of it! The period
>breaks the string so it's not quite so wonderful!

Well, I announced it as two sentences, but maybe a comma (or
semicolon) would suffice?

So, this exhausted me. Maybe next time something about DISNEY!

Harald

PS:
Sorry for my double-posting, but the first one rebounced as "NOT
DELIVERED"?

--- (Harald Havas) (Email removed)
Wilmer Rivers
Oh, and as for Scrooge's will: neither Donald nor Gladstone
inherits Scrooge's fortune. In his will, Scrooge leaves his
entire fortune to Miss Penny Wise, to settle that mysterious
debt about which we speculated on this List some time ago.

Wilmer Rivers
Juergen Gebhardt
HARALD

The original name of Zwerg Zwetschge is Idgit the Midget. I get a perverse
pleasure out of these character cards. They are just so ridiculous! I guess
Americans would call them camp. The best yet was the revelation that
Phantomime rides a Kushimushi superbike. I shame-facedly have to admit that
because of these cards I am now buying MICKY MAUS regularly for the first time
in 27 years.

KRITON

Yup, your story is definitely the one Marco mentioned, except for the concept
of the longevity drug which was probably added by the translator. The story
was published here in Germany in the very first LUSTIGE TASCHEBUECHER when I
was seven years old and I reread it quite often in those times, always
wondering why Donald didn't want to become rich.

RICH

Hi Rich, what a surprise to meet you here. And Steven Rowe is lurking around
here somewhere, too. It's a small world!
As for moose (that is the plural, or is it meese?) in comics, there's also
Myron Moose by Bob Foster.

Keep on ducking!
Juergen Gebhardt
Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23