Keskustelujen arkisto

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
Author

Topic: BOOM!'s DuckTales comics

(294 messages)
MustangRockstar
This is a sad chapter for a franchise I have always admired. I think Ducktales has not been treated with the respect the franchise deserves or the fans deserve. This was a landmark television program that helped pave the way for higher quality television animation. Without Ducktales, there is no Disney Afternoon, no Warner Bros revival and certainly a whole lot more mediocrity in its place.
Ducktales deserves two things - a proper comic book series, even if it is only a mini-series, and the fourth DVD volume. I am tired of so many Disney afternoon properties hanging in the air.
Kneon
Quote from user: VesuviusKneon- So everytime you posted something, Chip Mosher would scold you? Why? You weren't employed by Boom in any capacity, were you? In any case, I'll bet he's blowing you up now! :o
I must've missed this. Here's what went down in a nutshell: http://dcf.outducks.org/viewtopic.php?pid=13950#p13950

Honestly, I couldn't tell you why. At one point, I was interested in freelancing for Boom! Not because I was a fan of Boom! (as I don't even follow superhero comics) but because I wanted to have the opportunity to work on Disney titles again. My memory is a bit foggy here, but somehow I wound up in contact with their marketing guy over some samples I'd sent in, and I gushed about my love for Disney comics.

He told me to basically watch what I said online if I wanted to work for Boom, which was very confusing as nothing I had said at that point could have been construed as "negative." At the time, I was a Boom! cheerleader, but I did wonder aloud how relegating the standard characters to "Elseworlds" titles would fair. I guess that was my "negative" comment?

There were sporadic emails back and forth to correct me on this 'n that, usually within a few minutes of my saying something I guess I shouldn't have. Again, most of these could be distilled down to "Hi. How are you? Stop talking."

At least from where I was sitting, but who knows? ;)

So once I figured out there was no freelance work to be had, and that I was basically being patronized in (what I believe was) an attempt to keep me from posting any "negative" opinions online, I started a sales thread to try and show the powers that be over at Boom! that these books were not selling any better than Gemstone's, and were in fact slipping very quickly in sales from month to month (save for DARKWING DUCK.)

That prompted my all-time favorite e-mail from Boom: that ICv2's numbers were inaccurate, and not to be trusted (and presumably, not to be posted either!)

If memory serves me correctly, I facetiously retorted with something like "Hey, if you don't want me to post anything you don't like, then put me on payroll and slap me with an NDA." ;)

Then again, maybe I completely misread his intentions. But having seen other anti-Boom sentiment online mysteriously... get gone, and knowing how they feel the need to reply to virtually each and every potentially negative post on the interwebs... I don't think so.

All I can say in retrospect is THANK GOD I dodged THAT bullet. ;)

I think Boom! has bigger fish to fry than to fume over one lowly freelancer who was only interested in working on a license they no longer have.

Quote from user: AaronSparrowWell, you've been blowing up my twitter account and facebook page, so I thought I'd drop in. I'm glad that unlike a lot of forums, you guys here at DCF seem to understand that Disney is not at fault here.
Welcome aboard, Aaron!

Quote from user: AaronSparrowIncidentally, I'd like to point out that editor Christopher Burns really wanted to make this title every bit as spectacular as the characters, and you, the fans, deserved. Unfortunately, his hands were tied at every level, and he has since left the company.
Oh, that's unfortunate! Did DUCKTALES #3 have an editor, or is Burns' exodus more recent? (Gosh, hopefully it wasn't because of the DUCKTALES #3 debacle!)
Kimba_1962
I haven't been able to find any previews of DT #4, but THIS ticks me off royally:
http://www.boom-studios.com/ducktales-4-cover-b.html
They are STILL advertising Pujol as the artist... and then they flatly contradict themselves in the main copy by discussing Castellani... who may not be doing the artwork himself!!
DuckburgUSA
Giving BOOM!/kaboom! the hypothetical benefit of the doubt for a second:

Let's say the wrong file was given to the printer for those 2 pages in question (remember I'm going into hypothetical territory here).

What should they do?
A. Own up to it, and swiftly make sure to let the consumer aware they're on top of the situation.
B. Keep completely silent, and go on, business as usual.

We already know BOOM!/kaboom! chooses a resounding "Choice B" - I offer this case only because I noticed the following article, here's how a CLASS operation handles mistakes, and owns up to their errors:

http://www.bleedingcool.com/2011/08/06/metal-men-losing-my-definition/

DC Comics might be under fire by some fans for their major character reboot plans, but they still make sure stuff like this is properly addressed.
Kneon
I'm sure that offering a replacement for one book won't kill a company the size of DC.
I'm not sure that's the case for a company the size of Boom!, especially if those layoff rumors are true.
But just acknowledging the mistake would be a step in the right direction, however. Boom! won't even do that.
Just check out their forum, and see how many of these Disney threads have zero replies. In fact, one addressed directly to Mr. Mosher has gone unanswered for weeks!
Link: http://forums.boom-studios.com/viewforum.php?f=8
Bizarre. Utterly, totally bizarre.
Jano
Quote from user: kimba_1962They are STILL advertising Pujol as the artist... and then they flatly contradict themselves in the main copy by discussing Castellani... who may not be doing the artwork himself!!
LOL Yeah, some funny people over there. Especially considering the fact that Pujol *never* had anything to do with the final series. And yep, Castellani definitely won't have anything to do with the comic itself either. His only DuckTales (and final BOOM!) work (besides some covers which were drawn before but published at a later time) were those first ten or twelve pages in issue #1.
Dutch Duckfan Down Under
Quote from user: Lars JensenDexter, the Doctor and the Swedish Chef... You have good taste in characters. I was just waiting for you to mention the Legion of Super-Heroes.
Nah, I'm not the superhero kind-of-guy. I have mention Back to the Future on some topic last year, which should give you a better idea.
Quote from user: Lars JensenQuote from user: Dutch Duckfan Down UnderLast month it would've been The Doctor (from the UK series Doctor Who - which Doctor I don't know)
Perhaps I can help you. How does this version of the Doctor dress?

I meant that I wasn't sure which version of the Doctor to use. Even though he's called THE Doctor, there's eleven of him.
But so far off-topic pop culture.
Kneon
Doctor Who + DuckTales = DocTales!
http://globalgeeknews.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/08/DocTales.jpg
Link: http://globalgeeknews.com/2011/08/02/ducktales-doctor-who-doctales-pic/
(The Doctor could fix DUCKTALES with a little "wibbly wobbly timey wimey!")
Lars Jensen
Quote from user: KneonDoctor Who + DuckTales = DocTales!
Thanks, Kneon. I've lost track of how many times I've been tempted to let Gyro build a TARDIS.
Kneon
Quote from user: Lars JensenQuote from user: KneonDoctor Who + DuckTales = DocTales!
Thanks, Kneon. I've lost track of how many times I've been tempted to let Gyro build a TARDIS.

That would be EPIC. :)
Kneon
Arnaud
DuckburgUSA
Quote from user: KneonMore on DUCKTALES #3 from around the interwebs...

From our own GeoX:
http://duckcomicsrevue.blogspot.com/2011/08/epic-duckfail.html

Comics Cavern:
http://www.comicscavern.com/news/2011/8/5/ducktales-disaster-disney-comics-fans-outraged.html

Even the He-Man.org forums chime in:
http://www.he-man.org/forums/boards/showthread.php?t=212546

Amazing, and thanks for the props, GeoX! Your righteously indignant post a few months back about "not accepting nephew doppelgängers" continues to make me laugh!

Quote from user: ArnaudFirst panel : dog ears

Next panel : human ears ! Amazing !

Good eye, Arnaud: that's another one! DuckTales #3 is becoming the "What's Wrong With This Picture" activity page of comic books!
Pete_Fernbaugh
Hey guys! I'm trying to get a response out of Boom! over on their message boards regarding the quality of the DuckTales comic book and the cancellation of the rest of the comics line. (http://forums.boom-studios.com/viewtopic.php?f=8&t=2862)
Their discipline in not responding and in ignoring the fans (i.e., their customers) is staggering and amazing. I'm not the only one who has questioned them about the cancellation of the comic books. They just won't respond.
Can they really afford to be this rude to their customers?? I mean, they are a small, independent company, right? DC and Marvel can afford to be rude, but I can't imagine them acting this way on a regular basis. Can you?
Vesuvius
I'm not surprised that Chip isn't responding; I'm shocked that they've allowed your post to stay up on the board. That suggests to me that they're not even looking. As soon as they do, I'm sure your thread will be deleted, and the banhammer will drop.
Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20