Keskustelujen arkisto

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17
Author

Topic: Don Rosa Library to be published by Fantagraphics in 2014

(247 messages)
Weareskint
Thanks Jano for all the information. I just backed the signed copy of Son of the Sun. I also almost ruined my Christmas present when I informed my wife that I was just going to go ahead and back the tipped in headshot pledge. Turns out, she had already got it for me :) It is a great time to be a duck fan.
Misterpom
I feel really lucky. I got to know the duck comics just a year ago and there was only the first volume of the Barks collection. Now we have also Don Rosa´s collection about to be released. As far as I know, it´s been a long time since these were released, before Fantagraphics got the rights. So I guess I´m really lucky indeed.
I never read a Rosa story. I´ve been "saving" them. I don´t want to read them on Comicrack or something like that. It´s not as fun.
Roger North
Comickrack? Is that some kind of website.
AzureBlue
Quote from user: misterpomI feel really lucky. I got to know the duck comics just a year ago and there was only the first volume of the Barks collection. Now we have also Don Rosa´s collection about to be released. As far as I know, it´s been a long time since these were released, before Fantagraphics got the rights. So I guess I´m really lucky indeed.

I never read a Rosa story. I´ve been "saving" them. I don´t want to read them on Comicrack or something like that. It´s not as fun.

You'll love Rosa if you like Barks.
Misterpom
Comic Rack (not Comic "Crack" haha) is a software.
http://files-cdn.formspring.me/photos/20130228/n512fa0c3b85f5.jpg
You can read comics on your computer with it. The images are supposed to be inside a RAR file. It's nice but it's no substitute. It's good only if you can't afford the comics or if you want something rare to read.
I hope Rosa is as good as they say. :D
GeoX
Quote from user: AzureBlueYou'll love Rosa if you like Barks.
Well THAT's rather a loaded statement, innit?
Roger North
Thanks for the info Mister Pom.
Gooey98
Quote from user: GeoXQuote from user: AzureBlueYou'll love Rosa if you like Barks.
Well THAT's rather a loaded statement, innit?

Yes. @Misterpom: IMHO, Don Rosa has quite a different style from Barks. Personally, I always feel like Rosa's stories are a bit more clever than Barks', and his drawing style seems a bit more consistent. Then again, his drawings have a crazy amount of detail in the artwork, which can detract from the plot a little. Personally, I slightly prefer Rosa over Barks, but I know some people must like Barks better, and Rosa does draw from Barks, and clearly believes Barks' stories and artwork to be superior. Either way, it all depends on the reason you like Barks' stories, and I would not say that if you like Barks, you will definitely love Rosa.
MustangRockstar
Quote from user: misterpomI feel really lucky. I got to know the duck comics just a year ago and there was only the first volume of the Barks collection. Now we have also Don Rosa´s collection about to be released. As far as I know, it´s been a long time since these were released, before Fantagraphics got the rights. So I guess I´m really lucky indeed.

I never read a Rosa story. I´ve been "saving" them. I don´t want to read them on Comicrack or something like that. It´s not as fun.

For me, Rosa and Van Horn are like two brothers born of Barks' genius. Rosa is the epic storyteller with a sarcastic edge; Van Horn is the light-hearted, funny stories.

Very different storytellers, very different stories. Both worthy successors to the master.
AzureBlue
Quote from user: MustangRockstarQuote from user: misterpomI feel really lucky. I got to know the duck comics just a year ago and there was only the first volume of the Barks collection. Now we have also Don Rosa´s collection about to be released. As far as I know, it´s been a long time since these were released, before Fantagraphics got the rights. So I guess I´m really lucky indeed.

I never read a Rosa story. I´ve been "saving" them. I don´t want to read them on Comicrack or something like that. It´s not as fun.

For me, Rosa and Van Horn are like two brothers born of Barks' genius. Rosa is the epic storyteller with a sarcastic edge; Van Horn is the light-hearted, funny stories.

Very different storytellers, very different stories. Both worthy successors to the master.

Exactly. I feel like I said something along these lines on the board before, but not as well-worded.
Misterpom
Roger North: you're welcome. :D
Thank you guys for all the feedback. You certainly got me hyped right now.
Are Rosa's stories more clever than Barks'? Wow, what a great thing! I can't imagine that, though! Barks has some very clever storytelling. I like his drawing as well. I feel like it's almost minimalist and everything is very "round" and "cute". I think it looks great. There's also something about his tales that are moral but not preachy or moralistic. I like his messages and his character development. His characters are multidimensional and they serve the story rather than the story serving them. I love this.
Is there any chance we'll ever get a Fantagraphics Van Horn collection? Haha. I know it's soon but when Rosa collection ends, they sure could keep a second line alive with Van Horn. Any thoughts? :P
Roger North
I think they should make a collection of William Van Horn stories too. They already have collections by the other three best Disney Comic Artists Carl Barks, Floyd Gottfredson, and Don Rosa. Why not add William Van Horn too?
Gooey98
Quote from user: Gooey98Personally, I always feel like Rosa's stories are a bit more clever than Barks', and his drawing style seems a bit more consistent.
Quote from user: misterpomAre Rosa's stories more clever than Barks'? Wow, what a great thing! I can't imagine that, though! Barks has some very clever storytelling. I like his drawing as well. I feel like it's almost minimalist and everything is very "round" and "cute". I think it looks great. There's also something about his tales that are moral but not preachy or moralistic. I like his messages and his character development. His characters are multidimensional and they serve the story rather than the story serving them. I love this.
When I say more clever, I just mean that they feel like they have a lot more subtle humor to them then Barks' did. I could be wrong though. Barks' drawing is superb. "Experts" would say that Rosa's drawing is inferior. Rosa's seems very...geometric to me. And it's definitely the opposite of minimalistic. I don't think that geometric is the word I'm looking for, but the drawings seem to have very exact and intentional proportions. Plus the extra, possibly annoying detail thrown in.
AzureBlue
Quote from user: GeoXQuote from user: AzureBlueYou'll love Rosa if you like Barks.
Well THAT's rather a loaded statement, innit?

Shhhh I like making blanket statements.
Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17