I'm putting to this for all to see:
YMH at aol.com wrote:
> Er... what eyes? (I'm showing my ignorance here).
>
> Look at the way Disney Ducks' eye pupils are drawn in different
> places. They're seldom just black ellipses; usually they have a spot
> of white in there to lend them dimensionality or detail or something.
> In animation and most merchandise, the ducks' eyes have a little white
> circle missing to make them look shiny. But in the comics, instead of
> this little white circle, they have a triangle missing, as if someone
> had cut a slice out of a pie. I was just saying that I happen to
> prefer the glimmer style to the missing-pie-wedge style.
Ah, I get it now. Yes, I definetely agree. I've always kind of disliked
the missing-pie-wedge style, too.
> Don doing just the scripts wouldn't be the same.
>
> True, but it wouldn't necessarily be worse; just different.
Well, there *are* some excellent artist that might do justice to Don's
writing. Personally, I'd still like to see only short gag-stories drawn
by others. Don does so much research on the graphical details of those
historical adventure stories that artist-only types probably wouldn't
be able to do (lack of time, interest of ability for extensive research).
> But Don already explained
> his own view of creating comics, so I don't go there.
>
> Oh? What is this explanation?
I am referring to his latest DCML-message. Basically it says he couldn't
separate the writing and drawing part, since to him they are one big
process. Doing just one wouldn't be "creating comics" to him.
--
- Kai Saarto
http://www.go.to/donrosa
Author
Topic: 200309
(480 messages)
Kai Saarto
DCML Digest, Vol 7, Issue 30
Message 301 -
2003-09-17 at 08:02:49
YMH
DCML Digest, Vol 7, Issue 30
Message 302 -
2003-09-17 at 08:27:03
Oh, sorry. I must not have seen this yet since I suscribe to the digest
version of the list.
-Yossi
In a message dated 9/17/2003 1:02:33 AM Eastern Daylight Time,
ksaarto at mbnet.fi writes:
I am referring to his latest DCML-message. Basically it says he couldn't
separate the writing and drawing part, since to him they are one big
process. Doing just one wouldn't be "creating comics" to him.
version of the list.
-Yossi
In a message dated 9/17/2003 1:02:33 AM Eastern Daylight Time,
ksaarto at mbnet.fi writes:
I am referring to his latest DCML-message. Basically it says he couldn't
separate the writing and drawing part, since to him they are one big
process. Doing just one wouldn't be "creating comics" to him.
Josef Thörnberg
Whos the best?
Message 303 -
2003-09-18 at 11:41:00
I have heard people arguing about whos best of carl barks and don
rosa,whatdo you think??
_________________________________________________________________
Hitta r?tt k?pare p? MSN K?p & S?lj http://www.msn.se/koposalj
rosa,whatdo you think??
_________________________________________________________________
Hitta r?tt k?pare p? MSN K?p & S?lj http://www.msn.se/koposalj
Daniel Van Eijmeren
Whos the best?
Message 304 -
2003-09-18 at 13:26:27
JOSEF THORNBERG, 18-09-2003:
> I have heard people arguing about whos best of carl barks and
> don rosa,whatdo you think??
Generally, I don't like "who's the best" discussions if they are
limited to just a few choices. Such conditions tend to open a door
to lots of quarrels, while the answers remain pointless.
And why don't you share *your* opinion, instead of only asking for
other people's opinions?
--- Dani?l
> I have heard people arguing about whos best of carl barks and
> don rosa,whatdo you think??
Generally, I don't like "who's the best" discussions if they are
limited to just a few choices. Such conditions tend to open a door
to lots of quarrels, while the answers remain pointless.
And why don't you share *your* opinion, instead of only asking for
other people's opinions?
--- Dani?l
Mogens Sørensen
Whos the best?
Message 305 -
2003-09-18 at 14:18:13
Barks with no doubt. Not that Rosa is bad
----- Original Message -----
From: "josef th?rnberg" <rocker_boy_1 at hotmail.com>
To: <dcml at stp.ling.uu.se>
Sent: Thursday, September 18, 2003 10:41 AM
Subject: whos the best?
> I have heard people arguing about whos best of carl barks and don
> rosa,whatdo you think??
>
> _________________________________________________________________
> Hitta r?tt k?pare p? MSN K?p & S?lj http://www.msn.se/koposalj
>
>
----- Original Message -----
From: "josef th?rnberg" <rocker_boy_1 at hotmail.com>
To: <dcml at stp.ling.uu.se>
Sent: Thursday, September 18, 2003 10:41 AM
Subject: whos the best?
> I have heard people arguing about whos best of carl barks and don
> rosa,whatdo you think??
>
> _________________________________________________________________
> Hitta r?tt k?pare p? MSN K?p & S?lj http://www.msn.se/koposalj
>
>
Cord Wiljes
AW: whos the best?
Message 306 -
2003-09-18 at 14:57:36
josef th?rnberg wrote:
> (...) whos best of carl barks and don rosa,whatdo you think??
Here are those which immediately spring to mind:
Barks: Lost in the Andes; The Swimming Race
Rosa: The Pied Piper of Duckburg
Cord
> (...) whos best of carl barks and don rosa,whatdo you think??
Here are those which immediately spring to mind:
Barks: Lost in the Andes; The Swimming Race
Rosa: The Pied Piper of Duckburg
Cord
Rodney-selfhelpbikeco
DCML Digest, Vol 7, Issue 36
Message 307 -
2003-09-18 at 15:44:14
>I have heard people arguing about whos best of carl barks and don
>rosa,whatdo you think??
Lately, I enjoy reading Rosa more, but I think Barks was more revolutionary, in that he created the foundation that Rosa bases his stories on.
But really, in some way or another, this topic is discussed almost daily on DCML.....
rodney.
________________________________________________________________
The best thing to hit the internet in years - Juno SpeedBand!
Surf the web up to FIVE TIMES FASTER!
Only $14.95/ month - visit www.juno.com to sign up today!
>rosa,whatdo you think??
Lately, I enjoy reading Rosa more, but I think Barks was more revolutionary, in that he created the foundation that Rosa bases his stories on.
But really, in some way or another, this topic is discussed almost daily on DCML.....
rodney.
________________________________________________________________
The best thing to hit the internet in years - Juno SpeedBand!
Surf the web up to FIVE TIMES FASTER!
Only $14.95/ month - visit www.juno.com to sign up today!
KUR
Whos the best?
Message 308 -
2003-09-18 at 15:50:36
> I have heard people arguing about whos best of carl barks and don
> rosa,whatdo you think??
>
Well, I personly prefer Don Rosa but Carl Barks are god to.
Yours
Maciek
> rosa,whatdo you think??
>
Well, I personly prefer Don Rosa but Carl Barks are god to.
Yours
Maciek
Danshane
DCML Digest, Vol 7, Issue 36
Message 309 -
2003-09-18 at 16:04:43
NOBODY IMPORTANT WROTE:
> I have heard people arguing about whos best of carl barks and don
> rosa,whatdo you think??
AND I RESPOND:
Fee, fi, fo fum. I think I know a troll when I see one. If I'm mistaken, I apologize, but I wait to be proved wrong. I strongly recommend that NO ONE answers this meaningless question.
Dan
> I have heard people arguing about whos best of carl barks and don
> rosa,whatdo you think??
AND I RESPOND:
Fee, fi, fo fum. I think I know a troll when I see one. If I'm mistaken, I apologize, but I wait to be proved wrong. I strongly recommend that NO ONE answers this meaningless question.
Dan
Arie Fachrisal
Who's the best?
Message 310 -
2003-09-18 at 16:54:39
> From: josef th?rnberg<rocker_boy_1 at hotmail.com>
> I have heard people arguing about whos best of carl barks and don
> rosa,whatdo you think??
I believe it depends on each and every people's personal subjective choice.
I, for one, dont like to compare the two of them. Comparing arts is really a
nuisance. There is no better art than other art but there are some sort of
arts that will be appreciated more by a certain segment of people and
disliked by others etc. I believe all of that is more of a personal
choice/view/opinion rather than an exact "knowledge" of which one's the
best.
Can you name the best writer in literature history ever? Some people might
say Shakespeare, some might say the person who wrote the bible, some others
might say it's Tolkien.
Keep On Quacking,
Arie Fachrisal enjoying a nice plum candy.
> I have heard people arguing about whos best of carl barks and don
> rosa,whatdo you think??
I believe it depends on each and every people's personal subjective choice.
I, for one, dont like to compare the two of them. Comparing arts is really a
nuisance. There is no better art than other art but there are some sort of
arts that will be appreciated more by a certain segment of people and
disliked by others etc. I believe all of that is more of a personal
choice/view/opinion rather than an exact "knowledge" of which one's the
best.
Can you name the best writer in literature history ever? Some people might
say Shakespeare, some might say the person who wrote the bible, some others
might say it's Tolkien.
Keep On Quacking,
Arie Fachrisal enjoying a nice plum candy.
Mateusz Lis
Whos the best?
Message 311 -
2003-09-18 at 19:38:56
Maciek Kur:
> Well, I personly prefer Don Rosa but Carl Barks are god to.
God? I'll be grateful if you admit me to your Church :-)
Best wishes,
Mateusz Lis
> Well, I personly prefer Don Rosa but Carl Barks are god to.
God? I'll be grateful if you admit me to your Church :-)
Best wishes,
Mateusz Lis
Katie Sullivan
DCML Digest, Vol 7, Issue 36
Message 312 -
2003-09-18 at 20:43:07
> From: josef thörnberg <rocker_boy_1 at hotmail.com>
> Subject: whos the best?
> Date: Thu, 18 Sep 2003 08:41:00 +0000
> To: dcml at stp.ling.uu.se
>
> I have heard people arguing about whos best of carl barks and
> don
> rosa,whatdo you think??
There is no "best." It's comparing apples and oranges. Artists
each have their own style, their own strengths and weaknesses.
So much depends on personal taste and opinion. There is no
"best" or "better" artist. There is only "best" or "better" in
*your opinion.* Which makes it impossible to start a reasonable
debate with a question like this.
Katie Sullivan
http://www.sullivanet.com (still down, coming back soon)
__________________________________
Do you Yahoo!?
Yahoo! SiteBuilder - Free, easy-to-use web site design software
http://sitebuilder.yahoo.com
> Subject: whos the best?
> Date: Thu, 18 Sep 2003 08:41:00 +0000
> To: dcml at stp.ling.uu.se
>
> I have heard people arguing about whos best of carl barks and
> don
> rosa,whatdo you think??
There is no "best." It's comparing apples and oranges. Artists
each have their own style, their own strengths and weaknesses.
So much depends on personal taste and opinion. There is no
"best" or "better" artist. There is only "best" or "better" in
*your opinion.* Which makes it impossible to start a reasonable
debate with a question like this.
Katie Sullivan
http://www.sullivanet.com (still down, coming back soon)
__________________________________
Do you Yahoo!?
Yahoo! SiteBuilder - Free, easy-to-use web site design software
http://sitebuilder.yahoo.com
Mas
Oolated Squiggs on ebay
Message 313 -
2003-09-18 at 21:06:27
The Phishkissers have finally met their match!
http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=2952425192
http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=2952425192
Rich Bellacera
Whos the best?
Message 314 -
2003-09-18 at 22:17:49
Josef Thörnberg slips in a 'versus thread':
> I have heard people arguing about whos best of carl barks
> and don rosa,whatdo you think??
Uhhhh... Floyd Gottfredson and Romano Scarpa???
Thanks,
Rich Bellacera
(Email removed)
---- Msg sent via CWNet - http://cwnet.com/
> I have heard people arguing about whos best of carl barks
> and don rosa,whatdo you think??
Uhhhh... Floyd Gottfredson and Romano Scarpa???
Thanks,
Rich Bellacera
(Email removed)
---- Msg sent via CWNet - http://cwnet.com/
Cord Wiljes
AW: Oolated Squiggs on ebay
Message 315 -
2003-09-18 at 22:29:40
mas wrote:
> The Phishkissers have finally met their match!
> http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=2952425192
Customers who bought this item also bought:
http://www.extonaustralia.com/category89_1.htm
Cord
> The Phishkissers have finally met their match!
> http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=2952425192
Customers who bought this item also bought:
http://www.extonaustralia.com/category89_1.htm
Cord